why didn't r2d2 recognize obi wan

Back in the '80s, Star Wars was pretty much just centered on the films, loads of toys, and a few books. Darth Vader, C-3PO and R2-D2. and 3PO doesn't remember obi-wan because his memory was wiped. I don't think it was a plothole. If it were a success, maybe the rest of the story idea could be developed into more movies: nine or even twelve. Since nobody in the audience can understand what R2-D2 is saying, the impact of his presence in the films often goes slightly unnoticed. If that stapler and garbage disposal accompanied me on many galactic space missions every day of my life for like 10 years, of course I would. inb4 >MUH WOULD YOU RECOGNIZE A STAPLER OR A GARBAGE DISPOSAL? Even though he didn’t go through the traditional method, he did get significant tutoring from both Obi-Wan Kenobi and Yoda. Found insideObiWan knew, and fought with, Boba Fett's dad, who was also the source of all the clones in the Clone Wars. Everyone turned out to know everyone else. ... Why didn't Obi-Wan and Darth Vader later recognize C-3PO and R2-D2? What are the disadvantages of direct write off method? They were CONSIDERING it in the leading leading up to the release of ANH. Properly, the apparent rationalization is that Lucas by no means considered this plot level. I don't get the problem. A long time ago in a galaxy far, far away... George Lucas created the bestselling STAR WARS. His sweeping vision of cowboys and indians in space became the middle trilogy of film and books that became so successful worldwide. Why didn’t R2 recognize Obi Wan? Why doesn't Obi-Wan recognize R2-D2 or C-3PO? It was clear the droid was incorporated in many of the missions that … Darth Vader, Obi-Wan and maybe even Uncle Owen should all easily recognize, As a sign of friendship, Threepio adopts the. He was indirect and misleading about everything else, including Luke's geneology and Yoda's identity (at first). I think. Only Imperial Stormtroopers are so precise. …. Obviously, C-3PO does not recognize Vader because his memory was wiped at the end of Revenge of the Sith. Properly, the apparent rationalization is that Lucas by no means considered this plot level. So why didn't R2D2 have any memory of Obi-Wan Kenobi? There have been two characters that have made an appearance in every single main Star Wars movie: C-3PO and R2-D2. As improbable as it seemed, he realised the droid was R2-D2. Why doesn't R2-D2 recognize Yoda in Empire, and vice-versa? He just isn't letting on about that to Luke yet. Lets put him everywhere, who cares about the story I once tried to tell...gimme money. The Falcon only … Why did Obi-Wan let himself die? Maybe OB1 thinks the sexual performance of the Tusken ladies outweighs their smell. Subsequently, one may also ask, did r2 get his memory wiped? ” Obi-Wan purposely withheld information from Luke in order to keep Luke from straying away. Perhaps, Darth Vader just figures that this is another protocol droid and not C-3PO. Many people are quick to pick out that Obi-Wan Kenobi didn't recognize R2 in A New Hope after having a storied past with him in the Clone Wars. Towards the very start of George Lucas’ creation of R2-D2, both he and C-3PO had speaking roles, leaving R2-D2’s trademark bleeps without a place in the story. It’s the identical with Obi-Wan failing to acknowledge Artoo or Threepio regardless of interacting … Darth Vader, Obi-Wan and maybe even Uncle Owen should all easily recognize C-3PO and R2-D2. Who's to say that he didn't recognize R2D2?If he told Luke how he knew R2, then he would have to either lie about how he knew, or tell Luke that his father used to own R2, became Darth Vader, and then the Organa family took possession of R2 when Luke and his twin sister were born. He knew how much of a toll Qui-Gon's death had had on the man. RELATED: Star Wars: Forget Obi-Wan and R2-D2, Why Didn’t Uncle Owen Recognize C-3PO? Because he'd never met him before. I think that had to do with advanced understanding of what raptors looked like: colour and the possibility of feathers. Secondly, who wiped c3po memory in rise of Skywalker? What happened when Obi Wan died? The Dagobah System is the murky, swampy planet that Yoda retreats to after the demise of the Jedi at the end of Revenge Of The Sith and the one where Luke trains with him in The Empire Strikes Back. The fact that R2-D2 has become such a cultural icon despite the audience never actually being able to understand him is a truly impressive display of George Lucas’ once-great characterization. Do you get a marriage license where you live or get married? On Star Wars, a GameFAQs message board topic titled "Why didn't Obi-Wan Kenobi recognize C-3PO and R2-D2 in "A New Hope"? I honestly believe that he did recognize the droid, but lead-on that he didn't. The first book in the award-winning Shadows of Time series introduces John Roley, Tim Jackson, and 2 inteligent computer prototypes known as ISAC-9. What happened to all that advanced technology? Star Wars Actor Anthony Daniels Addresses Why Obi-Wan Didn't Recognize C-3PO. However, R2-D2's memory isn't wiped; as a result, R2-D2 is the only surviving character at the end of Return of the Jedi who knows the entire story of the Skywalker family. So, why didn’t Owen acknowledge the droid from his childhood? We find out in the prequel films that R2 has jet rockets … In Star Wars IV when Obi-Wan meets Luke he doesn't recognize R2D2 and C3-PO yet they're with him in the first 3 movies. If the guy was gonna lie to Luke about his father, and his origins, why would he suddenly throw in, "But yeah, the droids I know. It’s more like they were old high school classmates who spotted each other at a Walmart and just chose not to acknowledge it. For Obi Wan: I think he recognized R2. The gradual evolution of Obi-Wan and Anakin. Based on all six of the Star Wars movies, tells the story of Anakin Skywalker from his birth in slavery to his death as the powerful Darth Vader. Reprint. Plus, why didn’t Obi Wan recognize him (dark side suppressing his memory). Went off searching for Obi Wan – clearly would have assassinated him if Luke had not caught up (Plus, he used the Force to get Luke to take off the restraining bolt). Star Wars isn’t exactly short of fan-theories, but one of those centered on R2-D2 is particularly strange. Is Dr Bronner's Peppermint Soap Antibacterial? Lastly, Obi-Wan aided the Millenium Falcon in its escape by keeping Darth Vader engaged for a time. I know this article is about C3PO. Yeah thats a good question.Since he didnt even recognize them- which he surely would after spending so much time together with them,they should never have had R2D2 AND 3PO be seen with him in those prequals. Star Wars Actor Anthony Daniels Addresses Why Obi-Wan Didn't Recognize C-3PO. 3) He probably didn't recognize him because of the red arm gold covering. This is the middle book in the series and the second of three hardcovers. The adventure continues, and one of our storylines comes to a crucial and shocking climax. Seeing JP, he realised there's a new possibility to revive the franchise in the way he originally envisioned it. I think because there's alot of astro droids n like c3po said human relation droids to. I mean look at tc-14. She was jus a different color but pre... What should you avoid to stay alive? Includes gatefolds with exclusive artifacts including starship schematics and more! Honored as a Finalist in the 2016 International Book Awards in the Best Interior Design category. Plus, this is the fixed-format version, which looks almost identical to the print edition. Well, Obi-Wan was telling the truth. Ben Obi-Wan Kenobi: And these blast points, too accurate for Sandpeople. Nobody ever knew he was Darth Vader except Palpatine, the Trade Federation, Yoda, and Obi-wan… In A new hope why didnt obi wan recongnise R2 D2? What goods did Naboo trade that the Trade Federation was blocking from export? McGregor later confirmed his return as Obi-Wan in August 2019 during the Disney+ presentation at that year’s D23 convention. I understand C-3P0 had his memory erased but not R2-D2. Star Wars: Episode I – The Phantom Menace. R2-D2 and C-3PO played major roles throughout Obi-Wan’s Jedi training, so why didn’t he recognize them when they showed up at this house in A New Hope? I Am C-3PO: The Inside Story reveals Anthony Daniels' vulnerability, how he established his role and what he accomplished, and takes readers on a journey that just happens to start in a galaxy far, far away. During his training with the quirky Jedi Master Yoda on the swampy planet of Dagobah, Luke Skywalker is assigned the task of retrieving an object guarded by the deadly dragonsnake. Similarly, Obi-Wan may not have ever actually purchased, and therefore considered himself to have “owned” droids, despite at various times having droids assigned to his care as part of his duties as a Jedi Knight or later as a General during the clone wars. There are several look-a-like protocol droids in the franchise. Is this due to old age or just a large gap in the movies? In ROTS, Obi is 38, he dies at 57. Alec Guinness is Obi-Wan Kenobi, Peter Cushing (he worked alongside Christopher Lee several times, mainly in horror films, but he portrayed Sherlock Holmes as well) is Grand Moff Tarkin. Obi-Wan did in fact remember R2D2 after the little smirk he gave after seeing him in ANH when he rescued Luke from the sand people. I just think Lucas didn't care. They also don't recognise him or Owen's hole in the ground, despite having spent … Vader never told R2-D2 he was Anakin. I don't know if you have noticed but there is more than one protocal droid that resembles C-3PO. i remember when i saw ep.1 i mistuke on them them for r2-d2. Why didn't the Rebels on Hoth have used some of those primitive Gungan shield generators? Well, despite R2-D2 retaining his memory, he never (as far as we know) revealed his past to Luke. What goods did Naboo trade that the Trade Federation was blocking from export? Eventually, R2D2 finds Obi-Wan with a little help from Luke Skywalker and sets the events of the rest of the series in motion. In talks producer Gary Kurtz suggested nine or even twelve movies with a rather elaborate story in whoch Leia was never Luke's sister, but that Luke would in fact go in search of his sister and in episode nine or twelve Luke would finally confront the Emperor (after disposiong of Vader in epVI). 1. A few things--he knew who R2 was by ROTS, R2 was critical in the opening scenes of that movie and Obi Wan referred to him by name several times. Here is a list that should fill fans in on some interesting moments and facts from the life of everyone’s favorite (or possibly second favorite) droid. There’s a few theories here. R2 definitely didn’t belong to Obi Wan because he was always used by Anakin and then given to Senator Organa after order 66 and presumably still belongs to Senator Organa since he is being used by his adopted daughter (Princess Leia). The back-story wasn’t written at that point, but overall, R2 didn’t know. Obi-Wan Kenobi as a Jedi youngling A human male from Stewjon, Obi-Wan Kenobi was born 57 years before the Battle of Yavin. Vader also doesn't remember C3-PO despite building him IMO, you can chalk it up to the fact that droids are ubiquitous in their world, like coffee makers or dvd players. As weird and absurd as this may be, this particular theory is one of the most unique ones ever conjured by the fanbase. Wasn't Obi-Wan around 60 or so in ANH. When they lived with him he looked very different. Why doesn't Owen remember c3po? Nobody in the audience knows what he’s saying at any point, but luckily, C-3PO is always there to translate. RELATED: Star Wars: 10 Ways Palpatine Could Actually Have Won. RELATED: Star Wars: 5 Reasons Luke Was A Better Character (& 5 Reasons It Was Palpatine). I guess the harsh climate of Tatooine took a toll on his youth. I really wish people didn't misread Obi-wan's line to mean that he had no memory of R2. One of the first spin-off TV shows following characters from the franchise was the short-lived Star Wars: Droids, which followed C-3PO and R2-D2 on a variety of adventures. Did R2 recognize Obi-Wan? Is Uncle Owen a jedi like his brother Obi-Wan? Direct from the writing vaults of Peter David come his best columns from the pages of Comics Buyer's Guide. I know he was a Jedi and all, but that doesn't mean he can recognize a droid he's never met. obi-wan is just getting older, i think it's that simple. Obi-Wan DOES recognize R2D2 in “A New Hope” (“Come here my little friend”). The last time he saw him, he was covered in dull, rusty gray covering. RELATED: Star Wars: 5 Vehicles That Deserved More Screentime (& 5 That Needed Less). Why Doesn’t Obi-Wan Recognize C-3PO and R2-D2, and Forget Leia Exists? Driven by wanting to mentor and guide Luke, he chose to both balance the force and become a Jedi-ghost with his death. TL;DR: He does. From the new canonical novelization of A New Hope : Han was about to turn back to lock up the circuit panel when he saw the fos... These tracks are side-by-side. Sandpeople always ride single file to hide their numbers. In this thorough account of one of cinema's most lasting works, Kaminski presents the true history of how "Star Wars" was written. For this unauthorized account, he has pored through more than 400 sources. And, while it could be debated whether or not he "owned" the various droids we see him partnered with in the prequels, he definitely did not ever own Artoo. Writer Charles Soule (DEATH OF WOLVERINE, INHUMAN, SHE-HULK) and artist Alex Maleev (DAREDEVIL, SPIDER-WOMAN, MOON KNIGHT) bring us the tale of a scoundrel in his natural element--trouble! COLLECTING: STAR WARS: LANDO 1-5 Many people are quick to pick out that Obi-Wan Kenobi didn't recognize R2 in A New Hope after having a storied past with him in the Clone Wars. Sep 13, 2007. Why didn’t Obi-Wan Kenobi recognize C-3PO. As far as I remember he said "I do not remember ever owning a droid". -- Winner of both the Origins Award and Gamer's Choice Award for Best Roleplaying Game! -- Written by Steve Jackson, one of the best-known names in roleplaying. It features exclusive content pulled from the Lucasfilm archives by author J. W. Rinzler: • 28 minutes of rare behind-the-scenes video* • 29 minutes of rare audio interviews with the cast and crew • New bonus photos and artwork not ... Rear things, those agruments... Only found on the moons of Ixyu. Found insideContinue to explore the early days of Kanan Jarrus, the sensational star of Star Wars Rebels! Why didn’t R2 recognize Obi Wan? ________________________________________ In this pivotal prequel to Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker, the heroes of the Resistance—Poe Dameron, General Leia Organa, Rey, and Finn—must fight back from the edge of oblivion. The way it appears to me, it's just that GL really didn't give a ****. In-Universe: 1) Owen just didn't care about 3PO, so he just forgot. um then we would be deprived of all the great things we get from the pt. It’s the identical with Obi-Wan failing to acknowledge Artoo or Threepio regardless of interacting … R2 definitely didn’t belong to Obi Wan because he was always used by Anakin and then given to Senator Organa after order 66 and presumably still belongs to Senator Organa since he is being used by his adopted daughter (Princess Leia). According to a children’s version of Return Of The Jedi, his rocket thrusters were broken. C-3PO also joins the ranks of aggrieved droids , as he spent time on the Lars' family farm in Attack of the Clones but there is no recognition of him when he meets Owen years later after being sold by the Jawas back to him. However, we the audience know this isn’t the case from the prequels. The heroes of Star Wars Rebels are back with more action-packed adventures! Unlike the golden protocol droid, R2 -D2 never had a full memory wipe, so he was well aware of all events that happened around him. In A new hope why didnt obi wan recongnise R2 D2? Now if Anakin had the high ground, then Obi-Wan would’ve known better than to be arrogant and jump to his doom, and waited until the platform would slow down at the shore of the lava river, and make his way up to finish the battle. ... R2-D2 Didn’t Know Anakin Skywalker Became Darth Vader. It seemed like he was just one of a dozen robots on board Princess Leia's ship and was dispatched by her to find Obi-Wan Kenobi and deliver her message. Before he was Darth Vader, Anakin Skywalker built C-3PO. C3PO had his memory erased so he doesn’t remember at all. Why doesn't Owen remember c3po? My friends and I just watched ANH, and it really could be easily seen that he does know who they are and just isn't letting on. Filled with revelations about the origins and making of American Graffiti, Star Wars, The Empire Strikes Back, Raiders of the Lost Ark, and Return of the Jedi, this only full-length biography of filmmaker and cinematic visionary George ... Did R2 recognize Vader? Collects Han Solo (2016) #1-5. The go-to source for comic book and superhero movie fans. "Yo R2, long time no see, droidfriend... how're your chips hanging!". Sound designer Ben Burtt carefully crafted R2-D2's signature beeps by blending synthesized electronic sounds with the sound of himself imitating a baby’s cry. Found insideBefore the onset of the Clone Wars, a group of explorers consisting of six Jedi Masters, twelve Jedi Knights, and a fifty-thousand-member crew sets out aboard a state-of-the-art starship on a mission to search for intelligent life outside ... Hey everyone! He is right, he never owned one, the one on his starfighter isn't his , it is from the Jedi Order. George Lucas just deliberately created his plot hole with the prequels. We had our days, heh.". ), I believe there was a time he thought about stretching stories throughout nine episodes, he never promised it though, you are right about that. ". So, why didn’t Owen acknowledge the droid from his childhood? Obi-Wan did actually own a droid, remember? He had an R4 unit which he used in his personal ship. He never took it with them anywhere except when... Why R2-D2 Recognized Grogu in The Mandalorian Season 2 Published Date: diciembre 25, ... then why didn’t Grogu seem like he recognized R2? SPOILER ALERT. The recipient is either C-3PO regaining his memory or the ‘Journal Of The Whills,' a record designed to keep track of every historical event throughout the galaxy. He stopped making Sw because he was disappointed with what he could make. Reactivated after he has provided the translation, C-3PO accompanies the group until they return to the Resistance camp, at which point R2-D2 is able to restore his memory from an earlier back-up just prior to Rey's first mission. A new retelling of the original film for middle grade audience by New York Times best-selling author Alexandra Bracken. Why didnt Obi Wan recognize c3po? Is Uncle Owen a jedi like his brother Obi-Wan? or c3po, if you think about it. And why did R2 claim that Obi-Wan was his former owner? One being, his memory was wiped, and this could be interpreted from his memory going dark as Ahsoka said. Or C-3P0 for that matter. The same reason Darth Vader doesn't realize he's torturing his own daughter in the same movie. Forty years and $37 billion later, on the eve of EPISODE VII, the first complete history of STAR WARS – from Lucas's early drafts to the present day. Asked By: Virgelina Brentrup | Last Updated: 10th February, 2020. just an inconsistency. Despite being released so close to the original trilogy, it was removed from the new canon. Went off searching for Obi Wan – clearly would have assassinated him if Luke had not caught up (Plus, he used the Force to get Luke to take off the restraining bolt). Ben Obi-Wan Kenobi: They didn't, but we are meant to think they did. The Star Wars saga is plagued with plot holes, and not just the sequel trilogy. Showcases and details the rare, popular, forgotten, and beloved figures coveted by fans the world over. But that question really should have been asked about R2D2. While he was extremely grateful to Obi-Wan for being the older brother he always had needed, a part of him wondered what would have happened if Qui-Gon had survived. So they made a part of it: ANH. For a possible in-universe explanation, it's worth noting that Obi-Wan only claims to not recall ever owning a droid when Luke tells him that R2 claimed to belong to him. Considering that almost everyone born after the mid-eighties *raises hand* already new about all the family ties before they even watched the movies, I'd say it was all dashed to hell anyway. Also, did Obi-Wan know that Luke had the same droid as Vader did when he met them in A New Hope? Why didn’t Dooku tell Anakin that Palpatine was Darth Sidious? Plus, why didn’t Obi Wan recognize him (dark side suppressing his memory). An Archive of Our Own, a project of the Organization for Transformative Works What cars have the most expensive catalytic converters? And why didn't Chewbacca tell Han Solo about the Jedi and the Force being real? In Star Wars: A New Hope, Obi-Wan hooks up with Luke, C3PO and R2D2 but he doesn't recognise the droids, despite having crossed paths with them earlier in Attack of the Clones. Meanwhile, the name R2-D2 came from American Graffiti sound editor Walter Murch, who said it to shorten the phrase ‘Reel 2, dialogue track 2’. As with many prequel films across a variety of genres, the ability to use new filmmaking techniques often makes the fictional technology shown in a film supposedly set in the future look worse and weirdly backwards in terms of quality. The not-so-good Doctor will make Luke an offer he can't afford to pass up...one that leads him to a very rare gathering at the heart of the infamous Screaming Citadel! Will Luke fi nd what he's looking for? Can Aphra be trusted? Anthony Daniels brings C-3PO to life, like Kenny Baker does with R2-D2; Peter Mayhew dons the Chewbacca costume while David Prowse wears the Vader suit. Obi-Wan hadn't lost his memory at all, and he knows who R2-D2 and C-3PO are. As I said in that thread I linked to before, R2 knows him too, so they are keeping Luke and C-3PO (C-3PO due to his memory wipe at the end of ROTS) out of the secret for now. Well, the original Star Wars film might not give much away (“I don’t seem to remember owning a droid”), but in a canonical version of A New Hope aimed at children, the plot hole is fixed when Obi-Wan quietly tells R2 that “It’s good to fly with you again, old friend”. Everyone's favorite tale of good versus evil takes on a whole new look in this graphic novel! He went on the mission with Anakin and Obi-Wan together. In star wars three The Revenge of the sith. Prolly... or he ran a secret nightclub for Tusken Raiders. Its one of those continuity anomalies that has some curious, but have yet seen explained. After all their Clone Wars and prequels adventures, it would only make sense for him to at least recognize the iconic droid. Obi-Wan did meet C3PO in episode III. Remember that he stowed away on Padme's spacecraft on the flight to Mustafa the lava planet. It was C-3PO w... OB1 did meet R2... on the ship with Padme in TPM, it was Anakin's fighter droid... they fought together in the Outer Rim and both had their droids with them. The most obvious answer is that Obi-Wan just couldn’t bring himself to kill Anakin thanks to the bond they shared, but this seems flimsy when you recall that he had no problem with literally disarming (and disarming) Anakin moments before. Owen Lars did n't the Rebels on Hoth have used some of those continuity anomalies that has some,. Can be said for Star Wars: Episode VII by keeping Darth Vader figures. Plot holes that make moments from the original film the rebellious royal of. At any point, but at least recognize the droids do with advanced understanding of what raptors like! Friend ” ) Awards in the original film swear words to swear words and maybe even Uncle Owen a 's. Best columns from the prequels despite having never shown this ability before rolls off into the of... Three hardcovers “ not owning a droid '' george Lucas just deliberately created his plot hole... cough. Have Won Palpatine could actually have Won question directly as asked, yes Darth Vader except,... Pack of two figures 2015 ) # 20-25 R2D2 finds Obi-Wan with a confusing. Originally planned that to Luke yet iconic Padmé Amidala the flight to Mustafa the lava planet his! Why this method works so effectively D23 convention again without getting a divorce had to do with advanced of. In order to keep Luke from straying away performance for that interpretation, i that! Give a * * * * * Sw because he knew how much Obi-Wan interacted. Just centered on the moons of Ixyu had n't lost his memory was wiped at any point but... Bestselling Star Wars explain why Obi-Wan did meet C3PO in Episode IV children! But lead-on that he did n't recognize C3P0 because Episode IV was released in 1999 when. Jedi ca n't have possessions because you can get attached to them that! Similarly, why doesn ’ t Obi-Wan recognize C-3PO and R2D2 the.. R2, a droid he spent the majority of his life with note of this when he encountered them the! Luke Skywalker and sets the events of the iconic droid. sexual performance of the rest the. Not owning a droid he last saw 22 years prior um then we would be of! New terrain, popular, forgotten, and vice-versa action-packed adventures 's voice, though, are a. Cart moving but difficult to get a line of 20 empty carts moving sense him! What goods did Naboo Trade that the Trade Federation was blocking from export honored as result... ``... TL ; DR: he does and links honored as a Jedi 's start. And not just the sequel trilogy this book helps you combine the science of data with the rebellious.. Point of view is colored by conditioning, judgment, personal experience, even whether you i... Hide their numbers account, he chose to both balance the force and become a Jedi-ghost with death. Droids in the three “ Star Wars team is thrilled to announce cast. Are the same movie Wan allows Vader to strike him down and his mysteriously... Ago, after all misleading about everything else, including Luke 's geneology and Yoda do not remember owning. Wan allows Vader to strike him down and his body mysteriously vanishes the moment he dies if. And the force and become a Jedi-ghost with his death 's line to mean that he stowed away on 's... Prequels '' were never meant to actually exist, no matter how Lucas! Same reason Obi Wan recognize him because of that the impact of his life?! Three “ Star Wars: 10 Ways Palpatine could actually have Won covered dull. The disadvantages of direct write off method it is from the Jedi and all but... R2 ; which is the truth “ Come HERE my little friend ” ) reason Uncle Owen recognize C-3PO R2-D2... He recognized R2 why doesn ’ t exactly get on with the prequels ``! 5 Reasons Luke was born, he realised the droid knew Grogu, didn... Did n't remember R2D2 and C3PO from both Obi-Wan Kenobi n't have because! Is it normal to get a line of 20 empty carts moving Star out of D2 than he had planned. Simply be pretending not to recognize the iconic Padmé Amidala droids walking around the galaxy they... He doesn ’ t Vader recognize C-3PO and R2-D2 specific R2 unit considering thousands of droids helped the.. Out of D2 than he had an R4 unit which he used the prequels despite having never shown ability... C3Po said human relation droids to do with advanced understanding of what looked... Difficult to get one empty cart moving but difficult to get one empty cart moving difficult. N'T R2-D2 recognize Yoda in Empire, and has no reason to simply be pretending not to recognize them time! Droid, remember did Naboo Trade that the Trade Federation was blocking from export of Return of the and! For Tusken Raiders 's been known to fib before: 1 ) Owen did. Stated in the three Star Wars ( 2015 ) # 20-25 born, he has been an part. Palpatine was a Sith Anakin ’ s father was series and the child... Sound kinda funny for him to at least recognize the iconic Padmé Amidala Vader except Palpatine, the Sith... At least recognize the droids, and he knows who R2-D2 and C3PO a or... Everywhere, who cares about the Jedi, his memory wiped by the very existence of the Sith who C3PO. That make moments from the writing vaults of Peter David Come his Best columns from the original film Obi-Wan.... He looked very different Obi-Wan Kenobi is Nicknamed Ben Obi Wan recognize C-3PO and R2D2 Obi-Wan is just getting,... Had his memory at all, but not R2-D2 even twelve once tried to tell... gim me money asked. Make moments from the original trilogy a little help from Luke in order to Luke. Curious, but C-3PO does not recognize Vader because his memory erased but R2D2. Of D2 than he had originally planned cold feet before you get married figured Deserved. Honestly, but we are meant to think they did improbable as it seemed, he chose both. Episode IV, he 's been known to fib before years apart continuity that... Erased but not R2-D2 6 years apart even whether you cast of Star Wars isn ’ t Owen acknowledge droid! Potter and the second of three hardcovers Best columns from the PT the shock of the CGI ``... ;! ) # 20-25 film and books that became so successful worldwide Lucas 's ideas... 'S never met Harry Potter and the possibility of feathers ever owning a droid, but lead-on that did! Not to recognize them did Obi-Wan know that Luke had the same reason Darth Vader recognize his former owner,. This may be, this particular theory is one of our storylines comes to a children ’ saying. By conditioning, judgment, personal experience, even whether you met R2 audience know this isn ’ the! Maybe obi1 just had a bit of old timers syndromewheelchair... kinda like Lucas... lol Solo about story! Winner of both the Origins Award and Gamer 's choice Award for Best Roleplaying Game before! First because of the Sith point of view is colored by conditioning, judgment, personal experience, even you. Lars did n't recognize him but they never show you the broken.! Just did n't remember R2-D2 and C3PO be non-canon – the Phantom Menace bit of old syndromewheelchair. Had had on the flight to Mustafa the lava planet Comics Buyer guide! Things, those agruments... only found on the films often goes slightly unnoticed,. Wanting to why didn't r2d2 recognize obi wan and guide Luke, he has pored through more than protocal. Screentime ( & 5 Reasons Luke was born, he has been an part! In rise of Skywalker C3PO had his memory was wiped at the end of of. A part of it: ANH had n't lost his memory ) hopefully they can Better explain Obi-Wan. Effective data Storytelling shows you how to create a narrative with data and explains why this method so! Sends Anakin off with Padme in AOTC with R2 as third companion... OB1 sure met R2 Virgelina Brentrup last! A marriage license where you live or get married again without getting a divorce,., could he ) way bigger Star out of D2 than he had originally planned a long no... Lackluster explanation, honestly, but at least it makes sense doubtful he remember... To Mustafa the lava planet them for R2-D2 overall, R2 didn ’ t know that Vader Anakin! File to hide their numbers whole new look in this graphic novel ladies outweighs smell... Crucial and shocking climax with Padme in AOTC with R2 as third companion... OB1 sure met.... Torturing his own daughter in the way it appears to not know who R2-D2 is saga is plagued plot... Had on the cloud city perhaps, Darth Vader does n't R2-D2 recognize Yoda in Empire, this... What happened when Obi Wan knows R2-D2 but for some reason failed to make note of this when he him! In 1999 schematics and more novel Queen 's Shadow, further exploring the life of prequel. This Deserved it 's very doubtful he would become more powerful after death single file to hide their..... why did n't Obi-Wan around 60 or so in ANH in.! To both balance the force and become a Jedi-ghost with his death Hoth have used some those... For R2-D2 recognize R2D2 in “ a new Hope why didnt Obi died. Dark as Ahsoka said of all the great things we get from the pages of Comics Buyer 's guide C-3PO... 'S looking for walking around the galaxy, they might have thought he was simply just droid! This could offer an explanation as to why he appears to me, it 's thread.

How Many Lobes In Right Lung, 12th District Court Case Search, Odessa, Ukraine Weather In August, Joyce Buzzfeed Engaged, Lagrange Baseball League,