Debbie Reynolds, the mom and the brother are all the same characters. General; Share.

As it turns out, Brown was filming Big Bad Wolf, another horror film, at the time and the alleged scheduling conflicts between the production of that film and the production of Return to Halloweentown led her to be unable to reprise her role as Marnie.

Brown was replaced by Sara Paxton because of "rumor" the movie conflicted with another movie she was … Kimberly J. Because of the scheduling conflict, Kimberly had to turn down the role. In this sequel, Marnie Piper (Sara Paxton ) and her brother, Dylan Piper (Joey Zimmerman), go to Witch University to attend college in Halloweentown.

The rumor was that the original actress, Kimberly J.

Brown (@OfficialKJB) October 13, 2018 Star of the original film Kimberly J.

However, when the producers were ready to create return to halloweentown she was busy filming big bad wolf. Exclusive Interview! Kimberly J.

Marnie Cromwell was originally played by actress Kimberly Brown when she was a mere 14-year-old. Now, 18 years later, the movies remain a … Kimberly J. Brown (@officialkjb) on Nov 22, 2018 at 5:49pm PST “It didn’t even cross my mind,” Brown tells us when we asked if she’d had a crush on him back then. Brown is the one who isn't coming back.

However the rumor turned out to be unfounded.

— Kimberly J.

Brown was 14 years old when she originated her role of Marnie Piper in the Disney Channel Halloweentown series.

Marnie Cromwell was originally played by actress Kimberly Brown when she was a mere 14-year-old.We watched Marnie grow before our eyes in Halloweentown, Halloweentown 2: Kalabar's Revenge and Halloweentown High.It wasn't until the fourth film, Return to Halloweentown, that Brown was replaced by Disney actress Sara Paxton, known for the film Aquamarine and the Disney series … Brown revealed during a YouTube Q&A with fans in 2013 that the “Halloweentown” book was made specifically for the film but was never released to the public. Return to Halloweentown (also known as Halloweentown IV ) is a Disney Channel Original Movie that premiered on October 20, 2006. It is the fourth and final film in the Halloweentown series.

It wasn't until the fourth film, Return to Halloweentown, that Brown was replaced by Disney actress Sara Paxton, known for the film Aquamarine and the Disney series Darcy's Wild Life.

Kimberly J. the producers didn't want to wait for her and casted Sara Paxton instead.

Brown played Marnie in halloweentown and halloweentown 2 calibars revenge. Brown returned for “Halloweentown Excessive,” the third installment, however was changed by actress Sara Paxton within the fourth, “Return to Halloweentown.” “In the end … it’s a call that got here all the way down to Disney and I don’t know particularly,” she says of why she wasn’t requested to be a part of it. ‘Return to Halloweentown’ Star Sara Paxton.

if you ask me this wasn't a good idea its never a good thing to replace a main character! Brown, was filming Big Bad Wolf when Return to Halloweentown was scheduled to shoot.

A post shared by Kimberly J. ... Kimberly J.